Allow me to sicken you...

[Erlkonig]

With my 68 Death Knight, I decided to level my fishing. When I hit skill level 33, I caught Old Ironjaw. And yet I can't catch that rat with Trelin. Go figure.

[Eabah]

This is me hating you. But only a little.

[mihrimah]

Now go up to Northrend and get that turtle.

[Erlkonig]

No, I'm going to wait until the quest that sends me to Ogrimar, and lvl my fishing there until I catch the other one. Then I can go after the rat and the turtle mount.

[Eabah]

I think they fixed that loophole now. Alas.

[Erlkonig]

They fixed the loophole, but you can still fish in Ogrimar without being bothered by Horde at least.